Everlane vs Madewell: Which is Better?

In the world of fashion, choices abound, and two popular brands that often find themselves in the same conversation are Everlane and Madewell.

Both brands have made a name for themselves by offering stylish, high-quality clothing and accessories, but they do so with distinct philosophies, aesthetics, and approaches to sustainability.

To determine which is better, we’ll delve into key aspects of each brand, comparing their ethical practices, product quality, pricing, style, and customer experience.

Ethical Practices

Everlane has built its reputation on transparency and ethical production.

The brand takes pride in revealing the true costs of their products, from materials to labor, and often shares the factories where their products are made. Everlane emphasizes fair wages and safe working conditions for its employees.

They also make concerted efforts to reduce their environmental impact by using eco-friendly materials and sustainable practices.

Their “Choose What You Pay” pricing model allows customers to select their own price, which can sometimes be below the traditional retail markup, making their ethical fashion more accessible.

Madewell, on the other hand, has made strides in recent years to improve its ethical practices.

The brand has started to incorporate more sustainable materials into its collections and has made efforts to reduce water and energy consumption in production.

While they do not have the same level of transparency as Everlane, Madewell has taken steps to address ethical concerns in the fashion industry.

They have also partnered with Fair Trade Certified factories to ensure better working conditions for their workers.

Product Quality

Everlane prides itself on producing high-quality basics that are designed to last. Their minimalist approach focuses on creating timeless pieces that can be incorporated into any wardrobe.

Many Everlane customers rave about the durability and longevity of their products, which contributes to a more sustainable approach to fashion.

Everlane also frequently seeks customer feedback to improve product quality and designs.

Madewell also offers well-crafted products, particularly known for their denim. Madewell jeans have gained a dedicated following due to their comfortable fit and durability.

While they offer a range of products beyond denim, Madewell’s reputation for quality is often associated with their jeans.


Pricing is where the two brands significantly differ. Everlane’s pricing model is based on transparency and affordability. By revealing the true costs of production and selling directly to consumers,

Everlane aims to offer fair prices. Their “Choose What You Pay” option further allows customers to decide how much they want to pay for certain items.

While this approach can result in lower prices, it may also mean that some products are more expensive than similar items at Madewell.

Madewell, on the other hand, follows a more traditional pricing strategy. Their products are priced competitively for the quality they offer, but they don’t emphasize the same level of cost transparency as Everlane.

Some customers may find Madewell’s prices more predictable, but it’s important to note that they might not always be as budget-friendly as Everlane’s offerings.


Style is a subjective aspect of fashion, and both Everlane and Madewell have distinctive aesthetics.

Everlane is known for its minimalist and modern approach to design. Their pieces often feature clean lines, neutral colors, and a focus on versatility.

Everlane’s style appeals to those who prefer a timeless and understated look.

Madewell, on the other hand, offers a more eclectic and bohemian-inspired style. Their clothing often includes playful prints, vibrant colors, and a mix of vintage and contemporary elements.

Madewell’s style is well-suited for those who enjoy a more eclectic and trend-driven approach to fashion.

Customer Experience

Everlane places a strong emphasis on customer engagement and feedback. They have an active online community and are known for responding to customer questions and concerns promptly.

Additionally, their transparent pricing model gives customers a sense of control over their purchases. Everlane also offers a 365-day return policy, which adds to the overall positive customer experience.

Madewell also prioritizes customer experience and has a loyal customer base.

They provide styling tips and inspiration through their website and social media channels.

Madewell’s loyalty program, known as “Madewell Insiders,” offers rewards and early access to sales, enhancing the overall shopping experience.

Final Conclusion on Everlane vs Madewell: Which is Better?

In the Everlane vs. Madewell debate, the “better” choice depends on your priorities and preferences.

Everlane shines in terms of ethical practices, transparency, and affordability.

If you prioritize knowing the true cost of your clothing and supporting sustainable practices, Everlane might be the better choice for you.

Madewell, on the other hand, excels in product quality and offers a more diverse range of styles.

If you value durability, particularly in denim, and enjoy a more eclectic and trend-driven wardrobe, Madewell could be the better option.

Ultimately, both brands have their strengths and cater to different fashion sensibilities.

It’s worth considering your personal values, style preferences, and budget when deciding between Everlane and Madewell.

Moreover, as both brands continue to evolve, it’s essential to stay informed about their latest practices and offerings to make the most informed choice for your wardrobe.





%d bloggers like this: