Bobbi Brown vs Mac Lipstick: Which is Better?

Lipstick has been a staple in makeup bags for decades, adding a pop of color and enhancing one’s overall look.

Two iconic brands that have consistently delivered high-quality lipsticks are Bobbi Brown and MAC. Each brand has its own unique characteristics, shade ranges, and formulations, making it challenging to determine which is better.

In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll delve into the world of Bobbi Brown and MAC lipsticks to help you decide which brand might be the right fit for your makeup preferences and needs.

Brand Overview

Bobbi Brown:

Bobbi Brown is renowned for its “natural beauty” approach to makeup.

Founded by makeup artist Bobbi Brown in 1991, the brand has always focused on enhancing one’s natural beauty rather than masking it.

Bobbi Brown lipsticks are known for their rich, creamy textures and an emphasis on creating flattering nude and neutral shades that suit a wide range of skin tones.

The brand also prides itself on using clean ingredients and skincare-infused formulas in many of its products.


MAC (Make-up Art Cosmetics) is a global cosmetics brand that has been a favorite among professional makeup artists and makeup enthusiasts alike since its inception in 1984.

MAC is famous for its bold and diverse shade range, offering a wide spectrum of colors, from classic reds to avant-garde hues.

MAC lipsticks are known for their highly pigmented, long-lasting formulas that cater to those who love experimenting with makeup and color.

Shade Range

When it comes to shade range, MAC takes the lead. MAC offers an extensive selection of lipstick shades, from classic reds like “Ruby Woo” to unconventional colors like blue and green.

If you’re looking for a specific shade or want to experiment with bold colors, MAC is likely to have what you’re looking for.

Bobbi Brown, on the other hand, primarily focuses on more neutral and universally flattering shades, making it an excellent choice for those who prefer a more natural and understated look.

Texture and Formula

Both brands excel in creating lipsticks with different textures and formulas to cater to various preferences:

Bobbi Brown:

  • Creamy Matte: Bobbi Brown offers creamy matte lipsticks that provide a matte finish without drying out the lips. These lipsticks glide on smoothly and feel comfortable throughout the day.
  • Luxe Lip Color: The Luxe Lip Color line offers a luxurious, ultra-hydrating formula with a satin finish. It’s perfect for those who want a blend of color and moisture.
  • Crushed Lip Color: This unique formula combines the look of a lipstick with the feel of a balm, offering a soft, stained effect. It’s ideal for a casual, everyday look.


  • Matte: MAC’s classic Matte lipstick formula is highly pigmented and long-lasting, providing a velvety matte finish that’s perfect for a bold, intense look.
  • Satin: MAC’s Satin lipsticks offer rich color payoff with a semi-matte finish. They’re comfortable to wear and provide a hint of sheen.
  • Amplified: Amplified lipsticks by MAC are known for their creamy, intense color and glossy finish. They provide a bold pop of color and hydration.

Longevity and Wearability

In terms of longevity, both brands offer lipsticks that can last throughout the day, but it may depend on the specific formula and your activities. MAC’s Matte and Bobbi Brown’s Creamy Matte lipsticks, for example, tend to have excellent staying power. However, Bobbi Brown’s Luxe Lip Color and MAC’s Amplified lipsticks may require reapplication throughout the day due to their creamier textures.


Bobbi Brown and MAC both offer sleek and sophisticated packaging. Bobbi Brown’s lipstick tubes are generally square-shaped and elegant, while MAC’s lipstick bullets are iconic with their black and silver design. The choice of packaging might come down to personal preference and aesthetics.

Price Point

Bobbi Brown and MAC lipsticks are considered high-end brands, so they come at a higher price point compared to drugstore options. The exact price varies depending on the collection and specific formula, but MAC lipsticks are generally slightly more affordable than Bobbi Brown lipsticks.

Skin-Friendly Formulations

Bobbi Brown places a strong emphasis on using clean and skincare-infused ingredients in their makeup products. If you have sensitive skin or prioritize makeup that’s gentle on your skin, you may prefer Bobbi Brown for its commitment to clean beauty.

Cruelty-Free Status

It’s essential to note that both brands have made strides towards being cruelty-free. MAC Cosmetics, a subsidiary of Estée Lauder Companies, announced its commitment to being cruelty-free globally in 2020. Bobbi Brown, also under the Estée Lauder umbrella, has been working towards cruelty-free status but may still be in the process of transitioning in some regions. If cruelty-free status is a priority for you, be sure to check the latest updates on their policies.

Final Conclusion on Bobbi Brown vs Mac Lipstick: Which is Better?

Choosing between Bobbi Brown and MAC lipsticks ultimately depends on your personal preferences and makeup needs. Here’s a quick summary:

  • Bobbi Brown is ideal for those who prefer natural and neutral shades, clean ingredients, and skincare-infused formulations. It’s also a great choice if you have sensitive skin.
  • MAC is the go-to brand for those who love experimenting with bold and diverse lipstick shades, highly pigmented formulas, and a wide range of finishes.

Both brands have their own strengths and cater to different makeup styles. Consider your style, color preferences, and any specific skincare or cruelty-free requirements when making your decision. Ultimately, the “better” brand comes down to what suits you best and makes you feel confident and beautiful.